here is what I got.
I had to edit loop-single-reply.php after all,
I used a conditional to output the minimal layout only for single topics only.
I had to use bbp_reply_permalink(); instead of bbp_reply_url();.
Like I said you for sure do have to edit the bbPress reply titles plugin for what you exactly want, your gonna have to possibly make the reply title required as well.
You are going to end up doing a lot of customization to get the rest of the funcitonality, because I am not sure how submitting a threaded reply works on the other forum.
You are also going to figure out how to show the threads on the single reply page, for the specific topic they were originally from.
Bunch more customizing, much more than free support could possible help with.
I will share any custom templates I used later.
